Why the toilet spent centuries outside the house [Midweek Meander]


Hello Reader,

Congrats on surviving Monday and crushing Tuesday.

Now, Wednesday beckons you to take a break and step into a pattern of discovery.

Welcome to the Midweek Meander.

Did someone forward this to you? Please consider subscribing.
​

To the right of my primary bath toilet hangs a vintage sign that I look at every day. It's a reproduction of a Victorian-era toilet advertisement, and its earnest, overly formal sales pitch—paired with illustrations of early porcelain bowls—never fails to amuse me.

I bring this up not to brag about my impeccable taste in bathroom wall art, but because we're coming up on the anniversary of the death of Sir John Harington—inventor of the "Ajax" flush toilet—who passed away on November 20, 1612.

Looking at that sign every morning got me thinking about just how far the humble water closet has come. Today, every residential designer knows to allow at least 30" in width for the toilet (15" min. to each side of the center line, everyone say it with me now!) But the societal rules regarding the size and location of the space enclosing the throne, lavatory, potty, head, can, john, or crapper have changed greatly over the centuries.

For most of human history, the toilet wasn't a design feature at all—it was an architectural hot potato that nobody wanted inside the house. The journey of the water closet from a tiny corbeled projection in a castle wall to the star of today's luxury primary suite is a story of royal eccentricities, Victorian panic, and the gradual creation of standards and codes.

The Medieval Garderobe (A Room With a View)

A tour of White Tower at the Tower of London several years ago introduced me to a common feature of medieval castles—a tiny, closet-sized nook jutting out from the exterior stone wall, sometimes below and to the left or right of a matching one on the floor above. I'd found the garderobe.

A Norman garderobe in the White Tower at the Tower of London, one of six in the keep.

In the Middle Ages, residential "plumbing" consisted of gravity and a steep drop. Builders cantilevered stone chutes directly over the castle moat, a river, or a stone-lined cesspit. The waste, referred to as "night soil," was scooped out of the cesspits by "nightmen" or "gong farmers" to be sold to farmers as a valuable fertilizer.

But the smell lingered. In fact, the name garderobe actually comes from the French word for "wardrobe," because nobles discovered that hanging their heavy wool cloaks near the fetid shaft allowed the rising ammonia fumes to kill off fleas and moths. (Effective? Sure. A great selling point for a modern en suite? Doubtful.)

From a design standpoint, the garderobe solved two problems: privacy and odor control. Thick masonry kept smells out of the castle's great hall, while freezing drafts shooting up the chute kept the air moving. The downside, aside from frostbite, was security—more than one medieval castle was breached by invaders climbing up the garderobe shaft. Talk about a layout flaw.

A Royal Flush in 1596

For centuries after castles fell out of fashion, people made do with chamber pots and backyard pits. Then came Sir John Harington—Elizabethan courtier, translator, and godson to Queen Elizabeth I.

Harington was a character who had a habit of writing mildly scandalous poetry that got him temporarily banished from the royal court. While cooling his heels at his country estate in Kelston, he turned his creative energy toward domestic sanitation. In 1596, he unveiled the world's first modern flush toilet, naming it the Ajax—a saucy Tudor pun on "a jakes," which was Elizabethan slang for a privy. He even wrote an entire satirical book about it titled A New Discourse of a Stale Subject, Called the Metamorphosis of Ajax.

By modern standards, the Ajax was a beast of a contraption:

  • The Fixture: It featured an oval bowl roughly two feet deep, sealed with pitch, resin, and wax, with a leather-faced brass valve at the bottom.
  • The Tank: Above the ceiling sat a 40-gallon cistern. Pulling a lever opened the valve and unleashed a whopping 7.5 gallons of water per flush—roughly six times what a modern high-efficiency toilet uses.
  • The Room: Harington installed his Ajax inside a small, dedicated privy closet—an early Tudor powder room. Ever the thoughtful designer, he hid the cistern behind a partition wall so guests wouldn't stare at exposed pipes, built the seat into a timber bench, and topped the opening with a carved scallop-shell lid. (History does not enlighten us as to whether or not this lid also had a baby blue shag-carpeted fitted seat cover.)

Queen Elizabeth I was intrigued enough to have one installed at Richmond Palace, marking the first true royal flush in history (ba-dum-tss). Unfortunately, the Ajax had one glaring omission: it didn't have a curved trap to block smells from rising out of the brick vault below. Harington's workaround required a servant to empty the vault at noon and at night and leave six inches of clean water at the bottom. Without municipal water pressure or sewer lines, the flush toilet remained a royal party trick for nearly two hundred years.

As an aside, the Queen also found it "too loud and splashy," preferring to make use of the Royal Close-Stool which she took with her while traveling. It was a padded wooden box decked out with velvet, gold lace, and a silver bowl kept lined with herbs and flower petals by her "Ladies of the Bedchamber."

The Outhouse Era & The "Miasma" Panic

Fast-forward to the 1800s. Across America and Europe, the backyard outhouse (or privy) was king. Positioned politely downwind at the back of the lot, the outhouse was purely utilitarian—typically a rough timber shed with a crescent-moon cutout on the door for light and ventilation.

Even after Scottish inventor Alexander Cumming patented the S-trap in 1775 (finally sealing off sewer gases with a pocket of water) and Victorian plumbers like George Jennings and Thomas Crapper refined indoor water closets in the mid-1800s, homeowners fiercely resisted bringing toilets indoors.

Why? Medical science still subscribed to miasma theory at the time—the belief that deadly diseases like cholera and typhoid were spread by foul-smelling air ("night air" or sewer gas). To a Victorian homeowner, piping a direct connection from a cesspool into the house felt like inviting the Grim Reaper into the foyer. Early water traps often dried out or siphoned dry, letting noxious sewer gas seep into the hallways—which only reinforced everyone's suspicion that indoor toilets were a health hazard.

The 1880s Move Indoors—Under Strict Segregation

By the 1880s, pressurized city water, municipal sewer mains, and glazed vitreous china (which didn't absorb odors like wood or porous stone) finally convinced wealthy homeowners to bring the toilet inside.

Yet if you walked into an 1880s or 1890s Victorian home, you would never find the toilet in the same room as the bathtub.

To Victorian sensibilities, bathing was a refined ritual of cleanliness, while elimination was inherently dirty. Putting a toilet next to a soaking tub was considered deeply unsanitary—almost offensive. (It still is, to many people with standard 5' x 8' full baths that situate the toilet between the bathtub and the vanity, leaving the bather to stare over at the toilet while enjoying a nice soak.)

Instead, designers of the time would enclose the toilet in a water closet in its own narrow, separately ventilated room, often off a back hallway, under a stair landing, or next to the butler's pantry. Meanwhile, the "bathroom" remained strictly a room for the tub and washbasin.

The 1900s Merger & How Codes Caught Up

Everything changed at the turn of the 20th century. Germ theory replaced miasma theory, showing people that bacteria—not bad smells—caused disease. At the same time, rapid urbanization, apartment living, and middle-class tract housing forced builders to economize. Running expensive cast-iron drain stacks to two separate rooms made zero financial sense.

In the early 20th century, the tub, sink, and toilet finally moved in together, giving birth to the classic American three-piece bathroom.

Because early plumbing codes—like the 1924 Hoover Code and the 1955 Uniform Plumbing Code—only stated that fixtures had to be "reasonably accessible for cleaning," builders squeezed toilets into impossibly tight alcoves. It wasn't until 1958 that the Uniform Plumbing Code finally drew a line in the sand and mandated a 15-inch centerline clearance (30 inches total width)—a rule that became national residential gospel in 1971 and lives on today in IRC Section R307.1.

Full Circle in Today's Primary Suite

Which brings us right back to planning out the most important room in the house—and to that vintage ad hanging next to my own toilet.

If you look at how we design primary bathrooms today, we've come full circle. After a century of sharing space with the tub and vanity, the modern water closet has reclaimed its Victorian independence—now neatly tucked behind a pocket door with its own dedicated exhaust fan, acoustic insulation, and hopefully a window.

We still build around that 1958 30-inch minimum (though I try for 36 inches if at all possible, considering a variety of ages and body sizes, whenever the floor plan allows). Now, though, we're specifying wall-hung toilets, concealed in-wall tanks, and heated bidet seats. Sir John Harington would be thrilled—though he'd probably still insist on a scallop-shell lid.

Random Fun Facts

  • Other names for the garderobe include such gems as Golden Tower, Siege-House, Privy Chamber, Gong, and Necessarium (my personal favorite).
  • The origin of "john" as a nickname for the toilet is debated. Sir John Harington is often credited with it, but some etymologists point instead to older slang like "jakes" and "Cousin John." Another Victorian star of the bathroom was the "Dolphin," a popular English washout toilet made by Edward Johns & Co. of Armitage, Staffordshire, in the late 1800s. Its dolphin-shaped design (and the maker's name stamped on each piece) is still prized by antique collectors today.
  • If you watched "Game of Thrones" you no doubt recall a certain Lannister being murdered while indisposed in the privy. That was a garderobe!

Tracy Moller

Owner, Fine Line Home Design LLC​

Chairwoman, AIBD, Eastern Shore Chapter

PS - Sir John Harington's satirical book about his invention, A New Discourse of a Stale Subject, Called the Metamorphosis of Ajax, is available free online as a PDF. It looks to be a cheeky read.

PPS - Share the Meander with your friends! Just copy and paste this link to spread the word: https://american-institute-of-building-design-aibd.kit.com/posts/meander-2026-11-18

Other Important Reminders

​

Thank you to our AIBD Corporate Partners. Their generous support champions our profession, and we encourage you to support them in return.

​

Want to get fewer emails from us? Update your profile to choose your preferences.

If you don't want to receive ANY emails from us, please Unsubscribe.

Contact us at info@aibd.org, 800.366.2423, or 110 Front Street, Suite #300, Jupiter, FL 33477.

Any opinions expressed in this email are those of the authors or persons quoted and are not necessarily those of the AIBD.

One more thing—we want to lead with transparency. AI was used in the editing of this email.

American Institute of Building Design (AIBD)

The American Institute of Building Design (AIBD) is a professional association that promotes the highest standards of excellence in residential building design. AIBD offers a variety of resources to its members, including continuing education, networking opportunities, and marketing assistance. AIBD is a valuable resource for anyone interested in a career in residential building design. If you want to improve your skills, network with other professionals, and stay up-to-date on the latest trends, AIBD is the perfect organization for you.

Read more from American Institute of Building Design (AIBD)

There’s always something new to learn at AIBD! From high-performance building science to growing your design business and improving your project workflows, we have some excellent continuing education opportunities coming up. Here's what's on the calendar. TODAY! Tuesday, November 17 | 2:00 PM ET High-Performance Homes Team: Selecting the Right Glass 1.0 P4 CE | FREE and Open to Everyone Choosing the right windows involves more than aesthetics. Climate zones, solar orientation, and glazing...

November 16, 2026, Edition #CreatingWherePeopleLive This weekly newsletter is created by and for those designing homes in North America. Its editorial staff is the American Institute of Building Design, Inc., the premier association of residential design professionals. Here's what you get: Field Notes Nuts & Bolts Workshops & Gatherings What We're Up To Amazing sponsors who help keep this newsletter free for the industry. Let's dive in. Email servers may truncate this newsletter because it is...

Here’s a look at what’s coming up at AIBD, starting with Coffee with Bernie this morning. Today at 10 a.m. Eastern: Coffee with Bernie Grab your coffee and join Bernie for “Creating Where People Live,” a conversation about the responsibility and opportunity residential designers have to create homes that support people’s daily lives. Bring your questions and ideas to share. 1.0 Elective CE Register for Coffee with Bernie Tuesday, November 17 at 2 p.m. Eastern: Selecting the Right Glass Join...